Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | sgallant's commentslogin

This is great. I need to do audio work this coming week and was dreading Audacity.

Try Ocenaudio - I’ve used pretty much every audio editor free and paid for and this is my go to for a free editor.

I also cannot understand why anyone would recommend Audacity.


Ocenaudio is closed source, that may be one of the reasons someone might recommend Audacity over it.

Hehe ditto

I get flak for this, but Audacity is my "proof" that GIMP's name is why people don't use it, not the UI.

Like GIMP, Audacity's UI is awful, but people still use it. :)


I used audacity 20 years ago and the interface is still the same. That is also worth something.

people use gimp too. and i bet there are more gimp users than audacity.

as for the UI, i don't get it. what's so bad about it? and how is this one better? i looked at both and ardour too. so far audacity is the only one that has a feature to detect silence and label it. it's pretty easy to use too. i use this to detect chapters and create a chapter index for audio books. last one i did this week took only a few minutes, and most of the time was typing the chapter titles into audacity. i could not figure out how to do this in ardour or audiomass


I spend a lot of time doing this too -- cutting up band rehearsal tapes into songs and exporting all. As weird as Audacity's UI is, I haven't found anything better than it at this.

Again, try Ocenaudio. I'm old enough to have used Cool Edit/Adobe Audition. Similar flow to those.

i tried it. i could not find any functionality to detect silence. also no way to label selections. or do i use regions for that? it says mp3 does not support regions. no way to export a list of regions with timestamps.

i spent about 15 minutes trying to figure out the above. in audacity the whole book was done in 5 minutes.

also, i really don't get what is supposed to be better about that interface. both apps have text menus with lots of functions, and you have to know what the functions do by their name. that makes ocenaudio no easier than audacity in my opinion. and it's not even FOSS.


Have you tried Ocenaudio (which is roughly the same as old school Cool Edit/Audition?)

Far more intuitive, I think. Keyboard shortcuts and cutting and pasting similar to what you'd get in e.g. Word.


when have you last tried audacity? it's been getting friendlier

Agreed but it’s still not a proper DAW and suffers from those limitations. It gets very rickety when you go beyond a basic stereo mix.

Audacity isn't trying to be "a proper DAW," it's OK to be just be an audio editor.

How much work would it be to compile Audacity for the web?

(I'm a bit behind on web technologies nowadays)



Have you tried Ardour? It's like a superset of Audacity.

Great use-case!


This is awesome. Good job.


Well said!


My kids would love this.


On a personal note, I wanted to thank the HN community. I’ve been hanging out here for over 15 years. I remember the day I stumbled on HN: I immediately felt at home here. I’ve learned so much from reading HN over the years. I think it’s fair to say that without this community, Brice wouldn’t be what it is today.


> I recently read “Good Inside” by Dr. Becky Kennedy, a parenting book that completely changed how I think about this. She talks about how the most important parenting skill isn’t being perfect — it’s repair.

Love this book! Just read it. Must read for parents, IMO.


I've been following their journey for a while and love hearing about their success


AI Scheduling Agent. See 1-min demo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pu5RQAGOaG4

Would love to know what you think.

Want to test it out? Sign up to the waitlist at https://brice.ai and I'll give you access tomorrow.


What's happening in the background to pull this off?


Hi HN! We're Scott and Logan. We're building an AI Agent that schedules meetings for teams from within Slack. Finding a meeting time that works for everyone can be a big pain but Brice has access to everyone's calendar and can book the meeting on your behalf (using context from the Slack conversation).

I'm looking for some feedback on this demo.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ayIG7BZPSTI

Would you use this? Would you actually pay for it? Do you prefer Doodle Polls ;)

Feel free to sign up for early access here at https://brice.ai

Thanks!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: