I was recording videos of lectures (a slowly moving person against a whiteboard with thin sharp lines on it, in a questionably well-lit room) and needed to encode them to smallish 720p files to be posted somewhere (ended up uploading them to the Internet Archive). This is not something that x264’s default encoding profiles do well on, but with a day or two of fiddling with the settings I had something I could run on my 2014-era iGPU-only laptop the night after the lecture and have the result up the next day.
By contrast, libaom promised me something like a week of rendering time for the three hours of video. Perhaps this could be brought down (my x264 fiddling got me veryslow-comparable results several times faster), but the defaults were so bad I couldn’t afford to experiment. (This was some four years ago. Things have probably gotten better since then, but I don’t expect miracles.)
while the lectures in they were encoding would definitely look fine with these settings, I have to question your baseline for quality if you’re watching full Hollywood movies encoded at CRF 30.
there isn’t an easy answer, as it’s always going to be dependent on the source you’re encoding from. That said, in my experience anything higher than CRF 25 on AV1 is noticeably compressed, even to a layman. I mostly work in 1080 and occasionally 2160, though.
i can’t remember the last project i worked on in native 720 (probably circa 2009?) and even now 720 is only part of my output pipeline if specifically requested by the client.
AV1 is bloody awful to encode in software.
I was recording videos of lectures (a slowly moving person against a whiteboard with thin sharp lines on it, in a questionably well-lit room) and needed to encode them to smallish 720p files to be posted somewhere (ended up uploading them to the Internet Archive). This is not something that x264’s default encoding profiles do well on, but with a day or two of fiddling with the settings I had something I could run on my 2014-era iGPU-only laptop the night after the lecture and have the result up the next day.
By contrast, libaom promised me something like a week of rendering time for the three hours of video. Perhaps this could be brought down (my x264 fiddling got me veryslow-comparable results several times faster), but the defaults were so bad I couldn’t afford to experiment. (This was some four years ago. Things have probably gotten better since then, but I don’t expect miracles.)