I wonder how viable this debate is outside of dev circles.
For example, if I'm new to programming today and I'm not part of any community that necessarily approves agentic coding or disapproves of vibe coding and I heard that C programs run fast as heck and I heard that I can automate jobs 1,2 and 3 with such a program, I generate said program and it works as expected per my limited experience then what's the issue?
Perhaps in a couple of weeks I notice I'm missing 1/4 of my HD space and I figure out probably via an agent that my cool C program is creating bloat through caching or creating hidden dot files, so I agentically/vibe-ally generate a patch. Maybe this encourages me to join a community of other amateurs or a pro-am community where I learn specifics - eg. the exact bug(s) in my code -- as well as metas -- eg. testing.
There will probably be millions and millions of people generating code for their own purposes thanks to LLMs, and the number grows as the technology develops and becomes more trivial. So I wonder how much value there is in the "how to think about this" discussion vs the "how to use this" discussion. It almost feels like religious encampments are forming over a false -- possibly manufactured -- lines of division
For example, if I'm new to programming today and I'm not part of any community that necessarily approves agentic coding or disapproves of vibe coding and I heard that C programs run fast as heck and I heard that I can automate jobs 1,2 and 3 with such a program, I generate said program and it works as expected per my limited experience then what's the issue?
Perhaps in a couple of weeks I notice I'm missing 1/4 of my HD space and I figure out probably via an agent that my cool C program is creating bloat through caching or creating hidden dot files, so I agentically/vibe-ally generate a patch. Maybe this encourages me to join a community of other amateurs or a pro-am community where I learn specifics - eg. the exact bug(s) in my code -- as well as metas -- eg. testing.
There will probably be millions and millions of people generating code for their own purposes thanks to LLMs, and the number grows as the technology develops and becomes more trivial. So I wonder how much value there is in the "how to think about this" discussion vs the "how to use this" discussion. It almost feels like religious encampments are forming over a false -- possibly manufactured -- lines of division